Ice Cream Sandwich Cake Three Ways

02 August 2011

I asked for some easy dessert recipes on Facebook and got a ton of suggestions, one sounded like the perfect summer dessert… ice cream cake made with ice cream sandwiches!  I made three different versions, an Oreo, a Coffee Heath Bar, and a Peanut Butter Cup.  They are so simple, can be made ahead, and taste amazing.


Here is the basic recipe:

  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 TB sugar
  • 1.5 t vanilla bean paste {or vanilla extract}
  • Ice Cream Sandwiches {I used 7 for each}

For the Oreo Add:  5 crushed Oreo cookies, 5 Oreo cookies cut in half for the top

For the Coffee Heath Bar Add:  2 TB instant ‘fancy’ coffee, 2 crushed Heath Bars, 1 crushed Heath Bar for the top

For the Peanut Butter Cup Add:  1 TB peanut butter, 4 Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups chopped, 4 Peanut Butter Cups cut in half for the top


Here is the tutorial for the Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Sandwich Cake from start to finish.  I will note the places where you will substitute in other items for the Oreo or Coffee Heath Bar versions.

047 049

First, you will fit a bread loaf pan with wax paper, allowing it to hang over the edge of the pan.  This will allow you to lift the entire cake out of the pan.  Fit the bottom of the pan with four ice cream sandwiches, cutting to fit your pan.  You will have some small pieces left over, pop those back in the freezer you will need them for the next layer.

051 052

Add the cream, sugar, peanut butter and vanilla bean paste to the mixer and mix on medium.  You will omit the peanut butter for the other versions and add the instant coffee for the Coffee Heath version.

054 055

Once you reach whipped cream consistency you will add in the chopped peanut butter cups.  For the other versions, you will add in the two chopped Heath Bars OR the crushed Oreo cookies.  Then, you will spread half of the whipped cream on top of the layer of ice cream sandwiches.

057 058

Then top with a second layer of ice cream sandwiches going the opposite direction.  {This is where you will use the smaller pieces to fill in if needed.}  Then top with the other half of the whipped cream.

062 063

Top with the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup halves.  For the other versions, you will top with the Oreo halves or the crushed Heath Bar.  You can then fold over the wax paper and pop it into the freezer.  Freeze for at least 2 hours before serving.



the cape on the corner said...

holy moly. yum.

Jessica @ Wanting Adventure said...

Oh my those sound yummy!

MommyLisa said...

WOW - yum.

Unknown said...

I am totally going to make this next time I go to the store. It looks so YUMMY! thanks so much for sharing.

Bunny @ 86n It said...

I've had these before, but they never looked as pretty as yours!

Unknown said...

Yum! Gonna try this!

SnoopyMeg said...


deborah said...

did you know that TODAY is national ice cream sandwich day? i don't want to seem unpatriotic. ;)

Just A Normal Mom said...

These look fantastic. What a fun and easy treat to make for dessert!

@JessEsco said...

Whoa. I'm so making the oreo one. Seriously.

Unknown said...

I wanted to let you know that I tried this and LOVED it! I of course blogged about it.

Just in case you want to see. I didn't leave mine in the freezer long enough and it started falling apart when I first cut into it but it still was hecka good;)
I love trying new dessert recipes...thanks again for sharing.

Post a Comment

Thanks so much for taking the time to add your thoughts! Comments on older posts are moderated, so if they don't get published immediately, don't despair.

Related Posts with Thumbnails